FANDOM


Old Family Recipe is the 7th of eight short stories in The Warren Witches. It is written by Diana G. Gallagher.

Summary

When Piper Halliwell hunts the family recipe for her Grams's special apple pie, she instead stumbles across a curse one of P. Russell's, Phoebe's past life and thinking it to be her Grams's, she bakes the pies. The next day, strange things start to happen: everyone who ate the pies are fixated to what they did just after they had eaten the pie. Now will Piper alone be able to reverse the damage done?

Characters

Major

Support

  • Wyatt Halliwell: Piper and Leo's firstborn son. He has powers beyond everyone's comprehension.
  • Darryl Morris: Lieutenant at San Francisco Police Department. He is aware of the sisters' secret. Accidentally fallen under the evil pie's spell, Darryl ignores his duties and plays online games nonstop.
  • Wayne Hoyt: Darryl's captain. Accidentally fallen under the evil pie's spell, Hoyt is obsessed with exercise.
  • Sheila Morris: Darryl's wife. She is aware of the sisters' secret. Accidentally fallen under the evil pie's spell, Sheila finds herself obsessed with gardening the front yard and getting into arguments with the neighbors about the lawn work.

Minor

  • Mrs. Hoyt: Wayne's wife.
  • Angie Shore: Robert's fiancée. They broke off their engagement after eating a cursed apple pie invented by P. Russell.
  • Robert: Angie Shore's fiancé. They broke off their engagement after eating a cursed apple pie invented by P. Russell.

Mentioned

  • P. Russell: Phoebe Halliwell's past life incarnation. She was the one who invented the cursed apple pie.
  • Penny Halliwell: The sisters' late grandmother.

Magical Notes

Potions

Vengeance Pie

A recipe invented by P. Russell to destroy a couple. Accidentally used by Piper to make someone become obsessive with the first thing they did after consuming the pie.

The ingredients are the following:

  1. Hand-kneaded dough
  2. Bottom crusts in 3 nine-inch disposable aluminum dishes
  3. 1 Apple blossom
  4. Apple-cider vinegar
  5. 1 sprinkling of Dragon's blood
  6. Vanilla
  7. Rosemary
  8. Cinnamon
  9. 16 crisp apples

Antidote Potion

Made by P. Baxter to reverse the pie's effects. Whoever consumes the potion will be freed.

The ingredients are the following:

  1. Half a cup of water in a pan
  2. 3 sprigs of dried clove in half a teaspoon
  3. 1 balm of Gilead leaf
  4. 1 crumbled dry leaf
  5. Powdered elecampane root
  6. 1 crushed eucalyptus seed
  7. 1 chopped dried apple blossom
  8. 1 dash of dragon's blood

Powers

Notes and Trivia

Differences from the Show

  • Darryl is addressed as "inspector", when he was lieutenant on the show.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.

Fandom may earn an affiliate commission on sales made from links on this page.

Stream the best stories.

Fandom may earn an affiliate commission on sales made from links on this page.

Get Disney+