The manor is besieged by reporters, among them - Seth Perra. Billie is after a demon, the Dogan, and persuades the sisters to let her go after him, since the press doesn't know her. Piper turns three reporters into rats.

Phoebe has taken a pregnancy test and it was positive; but Dex has reacted badly to her being a witch and she doesn't know how to tell him. Their marriage has been annulled.


Billie tracks down the Dogan and is listening to him talk with another demon, Tomar, when the memory of her sister's kidnapping comes back to her. She freezes and drops her potion bottles, the demons hear, and she has to flee. At the manor, Billie admits to freezing up, and overhears Phoebe and Piper saying that she's not ready to fight demons.

Billie goes to the Book of Shadows and uses a spell to erase her childhood memory. She tracks the Dogan and Tomar down, but he gestures, and the spell is broken; he takes her potions, and she flees.


Paige orbs into Seth Perra's bedroom while he's sleeping. She assumes the ghostly appearance of Carol Flowers, a source for one of his stories who was killed, because he exposed her. She warns him about harming innocent people again.

Billie tries the anti-fear spell again. She finds the Dogan and throws a potion, but he deviates its path, vanquishing Tomar instead. She throws several more potions, badly injuring him. He flames into Magic School to escape. He decides to go after Billie to settle the score.

Paige calls to the Elders for help with the reporters; one comes down and refuses to help, but suggests showing the reporters an ordinary, boring life. She leads the reporters into the manor, to the surprise of Phoebe, Piper and Leo. She shows them all the mundane stuff around the house, including a spat between Piper and Leo. In the attic, she carefully stands in front of the Book of Shadows and none of the reporters notice it. At last, the reporters leave.

Phoebe has retaken her pregnancy test, and the new one is negative.

Paige notices the Book open to the anti-fear spell and fears for Billie. She orbs to Billie's dorm room, where the Dogan is beating her up, and orbs her back to the manor. She tells the sisters about Christy: she had been abducted by a demon and was never allowed to talk about it. The Dogan shimmers into the attic, and shimmers out with Billie; but once they shimmer into Magic School, she throws a potion, vanquishing him.

Phoebe and Dex talk about their relationship and about how she thought that she was pregnant. They both realize that they moved much too fast in their relationship, and they officially break up.

Meanwhile, back at the manor, Piper and Paige answer the door for some trick-or-treaters. They give out some candy to all the kids and they all leave, the sisters closing the door behind them. Leo is going to take Wyatt out trick-or-treating, but Piper has chosen to stay behind with Paige and Chris.

As Piper and Paige return to the couch after putting Chris in his playpen, Paige offers to watch Chris so she can go with Leo and Wyatt. Piper declines, figuring that she and Leo need some space. Paige and Piper talk about Piper's recent marital problems, how their lives will finally return to normal, and Billie's emotional pain after learning the truth about her sister's kidnapping.

Billie lies in bed at her dorm room, sadly thinking about Christy.

Previous Episode:
Next Episode:
The Lost Picture Show/Plot
Episodes: Season 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8
Comics: 9 - 10