This post contains spoilers, so for those who haven't actually watched all of Charmed. Don't read this. The description of this episode is: While slicing up fruit at P3, Piper collapses and is rushed to the San Francisco Memorial Hospital. -- My question is why are the elders okay with letting the charmed ones die with Piper?

Okay, so in this episode Piper is on the brink of death and the other two sisters decide to call upon Leo so he can heal her. In response Leo says this "I know. That's why I could hear you calling. I've been nearby watching." then "I can't. They know about Piper, too, and they won't let me interfere. Don't you think I would do something about it if I could?" This lets me know two things. The elders are aware that Piper is dying. Secondly, they won't help her live.

Now, we jump into the future of Charmed, Prue is dead and they are about to find out that their mother had a fourth kid. The elders already knew about Paige. That means that they know the Charmed ones will be safe even if Piper ends up dying.

In conclusion, what if that is why they won't let Leo interfere and save Piper? Cause they have a backup sister and don't care who makes up the Charmed ones even if she has already helped save the world multiple times? Yes? No? Maybe so? What do you think about this theory of mine?

Enter season 4 & we do not see Holly Marie Combs name until after the other 2 girls. For the first three seasons you see Shannen Doherty and then you see Holly Marie Combs followed by Alyssa Milano. Now I know they had an original Phoebe so maybe that's why they allowed Holly Marie Combs to stay above Alyssa Milano or maybe Holly Marie Combs was just very close to Shannen Doherty who is very close to Aaron Spelling, IDK? But when they come back after Shannen Doherty leaves you see Alyssa Milano first followed by Rose McGowan and finally Holly Marie Combs!? Now I know she started to do some producing but it wasn't at this point that her name was being shown as a producer, correct me if I'm wrong? But I felt like this was a huge slap in the face!? I know that the other two were bigger household names and that's how things work and that's usually how they list people in order of the credits to grab viewers attention, however, she had been on it for all three seasons going into the fourth and the reason why she should have been last. I will feel like an idiot if it does say she's a producer but I really don't think it in season 3 anyway, or at least at the beginning. I read online that was why, but that didn't happen I think till the next season. I'll have to check it out again maybe after a few shows it lists her as that, but my feeling is maybe she got upset about it and they gave her that title because they all gave input anyway. Maybe that's what they told her and that they were grooming her to be a producer and that's how they got her to have her name at the bottom, I don't know but I didn't like it.

Hey, does anyone know why The CW didn't just decide to do a next generation version of Charmed instead of the reboot? If they wanted to make the main characters more diverse, there's no reason they couldn't have done that with Phoebe's and Paige's children, or maybe even Piper's later child (I'm assuming here). They could have used at least two of the current main characters for Coop and Phoebe's daughter's. They really wouldn't have to limit themselves at all since we're talking magic. Anyway, just a question. I really need to check out the comics! Thanks!

I'm rewatching the Charmed for the first time since like many years and I'm on season 6 - Spin City episode and I think I found a small discrepancy and wanted to share!

Chris says that he always used to ask Paige for money when he's older. But remember the first episode when he appeared - the one with the Titans? He came in just the right moment to save Paige and he said back then that in his future Paige dies at this moment. So that means there's no way he could ask her for money :)

According to the Charmed Wiki Page Piper's birthday is in August, however in season two or three Phoebe tells Piper that she refuses to be out suborned by a Gemini, referring to Piper. Does anyone else have any further info on this?

I dont mean any disrespect towards most people who bust butt to write out the fandom pages but some of the grammar and writing is terrible. Seriously! I will give an example in the pic. Generally when you use the word "when" you're trying to give an answer, that plus run on sentences, come on its like a 5 yo wrote it. You're making these pages for people to read and get info from. They should at least look half way professional. I have read at least 10 pages today and all 10 were bad. Perhaps I am a grammar nazi, but if my name is attached to something, I would want it to be perfect.

Would a wizard's spellbook just be a spell book or would it have a proper, formal name like a witch's BOS or grimoire?

Would warlocks have grimoires too like evil witches? When the Charmed Ones were turned into warlocks because of Prue's Dark Binding, their Book of Shadows turned evil. Users still consider it a BOS, but their book was turned evil, so would it be a grimoire?

I was wondering which witch wielded the strongest powers for a fanmade story I'm working on, but I need some help with the powers. If you know of any other stronger powers, just add them in the comments.