Bloopers and Glitches

Throughout the series, several Bloopers and Glitches appeared. Below is a list of these mis-edits and errors.


 * Note: This page serves as a list to mention Bloopers and Glitches. It does not serve as a place where these should be explained, theorized or diccussed.

Something Wicca This Way Comes

 * In the first episode Prue uses her powers to tighten the tie around her boss' neck as she walks down the hall, but in future episodes Prue must be looking at the object she moves with her power
 * When Phoebe opens the door to the attic, she shines the torch in the room, however, when the camera changes angle the flashlight is pointed at the floor.
 * In the attic when Jeremy bursts in, two fireballs are thrown from his athame, yet only one lands to surround the girls. The other one seemingly disappears.
 * The tree in front of Halliwell Manor is completely bald the night they get their powers (we see Jeremy standing there in the rain). The next morning, when Piper leaves, the tree has not just leaves but flowers.
 * In the beginning when it's raining, you see Piper walk up the steps to the front door carrying a black and yellow spotted umbrella, when she gets inside, you see that the umbrella is solid brown.
 * In the scene when Piper and Jeremy are in the taxi, Piper gives him a fortune cookie. You can see her closing the box. In the next shot of Jeremy, you can see the box is still open.
 * When Piper first freezes Jeremy, his mouth is open, but when it cuts to the next scene, it's closed.
 * When Jeremy stands outside, after Phoebe invoked the powers, we can see three lights moving in the window, the flashlights of the sisters who check the living room. However, the next scene shows the sisters coming down the stairs. This is due to the clip of Jeremy standing outside the house comes from the unaired pilot. In the unaired pilot, they showed Jeremy only after the sister came downstairs, not in between the clip of Phoebe casting the spell, and the sisters going downstairs.
 * When the sisters are doing the spell before Phoebe's vision of a thorny Jeremy you see Phoebe push the thorns of the rose into the clay doll twice.

I've Got You Under My Skin

 * When Piper is at the church the first time and the pastor walks up to the car to talk you can clearly see she only has eyeshadow on her right eye and when she gets out of the car both eyes have eyeshadow.


 * When Stefan is giving Phoebe the address of where to go when she wants to model. Just before he writes on the napkin you can see that the address is already there so he pretends to write it.

Thank You For Not Morphing

 * One of the shapeshifters could open the front door by shapeshifting his finger into the key, yet he could not do the same with the attic door.


 * When Prue finds "Andy" in her house, there is a guy sitting in the sun-room in the background, most likely a crew member.

Dead Man Dating

 * While Piper is rushing to clean up the invitations for Prue's party, we see her picking up all the cards in her hand from a front shot, then as they get a shot from the back, the cards are still on the counter.
 * When Mark is shot dead, there is no wound or blood anywhere to be seen.
 * When Mark gets into the car, you can see it move under his weight - but ghosts don't weigh anything. This also happened when he sat down on the sofa.
 * When Wong has Piper tied in the chair, he grabs the back of her hair with his left arm. In the first shot you can tell that his right arm, with the gun, is relaxed at his side. But in the next shot, his arm, and the gun, are steadily aimed at Piper.
 * When Phoebe copies the Chinese characters, she puts them the wrong way around.
 * When Mark is outside the Hotel with Piper a car drives through him, but he can sit in Piper's car and be driven around. Also he can't touch the TV but can sit on the sofa.

Dream Sorcerer

 * As Andy and Darryl are inspecting Skye's apartment, Andy says that the apartment is on the ground floor. However, as he says this, the view of the Transamerica Pyramid through the window behind him makes it obvious that the apartment is not on the ground floor.
 * When Phoebe arrives home after she ditched Hans, she takes one bunch of flowers to her left hand and takes one of the chocolates to the mouth. When she came to the kitchen, she has flowers in right hand and the chocolate from her mouth disappeared.

The Wedding From Hell

 * When the demons push the girls into the bedroom Prue drops her purse, then in the next shot she has it again. We see Elliot Spencer roll off the bed to pick up the knife next to Prue's purse on the floor.
 * When Prue telekinetically throws two bridesmaids against a wall, you can see behind the set wall slightly at the top of the screen upon impact.

The Fourth Sister

 * When Kali appears while Phoebe is sleeping we see her in the mirror and along with Phoebe's bed. We do not however see Phoebe asleep in the bed. Instead the bed is empty and has been made.
 * Aviva leaves her sweater in the sun room but later it is in the kitchen.
 * When Prue opens the closet in Aviva's room the mirror shows her in front of a closed door, not an open closet.
 * When Phoebe gets the premonition of Prue being killed by Aviva, we can see Prue wearing the actual outfit she wore on the day, then Aviva, but when it comes back to Prue, she wears a leather jacket.

The Truth Is Out There... and It Hurts

 * When Dr. Mitchell was killed by Gavin, his eyes turned pure white, yet when the Charmed Ones saw him, his eyes were normal.
 * When Piper and Phoebe ran to the place where Dr. Mitchell was killed, Prue seconds later, which is impossible as Piper and Phoebe were way ahead of her. Also, Prue didn't have a reason to run there, because she didn't know about Phoebe's premonition.
 * When Prue was flipping through the Book of Shadows, she turned the page to the Truth Spell, yet in the next shot there is the Demons page.
 * When Prue was flipping through the Book of Shadows, the position of bookmarks changes in between shots.
 * When Gavin asked Prue about the girl she was standing next to the elevator with [Phoebe], Prue said "I don't remember," which was a lie, even though she's supposed to be under the influence of the Truth Spell and thus unable to lie.

The Witch is Back

 * In the beginning when Prue lets Matthew out of the locket, her hand keeps moving from at her side to on her stomach when the shot changes.
 * When Matthew is cursed back into the locket at the end of the episode, the sisters' heads move at the wrong time whilst he is being sucked to the locket.
 * Matthew broke Prue's window, but in the over head shots the glass wasn't there.

Wicca Envy

 * When the sisters are looking in the Book of Shadows, Phoebe asks if the relinquishing spell is reversible and Piper answers "It doesn't say". But if you look at the book carefully, you can see what's written: "This spell is to be used in dire emergency; not lightly, only by choice." and the next line says "This spell is irreversable".
 * When Piper freezes the room Leo is leaning against the door, but later he isn't.
 * Phoebe and Prue comment on Piper wearing a front clasp bra, but if you look closely you can see that she isn't wearing a front clasp bra.

From Fear to Eternity

 * When Andy bursts in on Prue in the shower, there is no white in her hair but when Phoebe comes home, the streak has suddenly materialised.


 * Water spills on Phoebe's dress but it is still dry.


 * When Phoebe is playing with her coin she picks it up and then spills the water - yet suddenly the good luck coin is gone.


 * If you look carefully you can see a big white spot covering Shannen's tattoo when she is in the shower.


 * When Prue is in the swimming pool her bra strap is white. When she finally gets out of the pool she is wearing a black one.


 * When Phoebe is sitting there debating if she should lie or not lie. You can see that there is no water in the water bottle. Yet when she spills it, it is full of water.


 * On the close up of Zoe's dead body, you can see a tiny bit of her dark hair poking out from underneath the white wig.


 * Prue's white hair disappears after the scene where she notices it.

Is There a Woogy in the House?

 * In "The Fourth Sister", Leo hangs up flyers of the "lost" Kit around the neighborhood, and we see that the Halliwell's address is 7571 Prescott Street, but in this episode, Phoebe mentions on the phone that their address is 1329 Prescott Street.
 * When Prue and Piper have to spend the night outside, you notice that the previous night, Prue had a black choker on. In the morning you can clearly see that Prue now has a simple silver necklace, until you see Piper go and throw a brick in the window, when we flash back to Prue, she has the black choker on again.
 * Piper is in the kitchen trying to make dinner. She puts her head in her hands and says something like "What did I do to deserve this?" Well if you look carefully, when Josh comes in, she takes her hands off of her face and it's clean. But, a second later her entire face is covered with flour. As for when she uses flour, you can notice Holly Marie deliberately put flour on her arm.

Which Prue is It, Anyway?

 * When Prue leaves Piper and Phoebe downstairs to go up to the attic to cast the multiplying spell, we see Piper's hair down - but as soon as she and Phoebe run upstairs and see three Prues, Piper's hair is up in a ponytail.

That '70s Episode

 * When the Halliwell's enter 'Buddy's' you can see a woman with long brown hair, and a man wearing a strange shirt getting up to leave. But later when Phoebe comes running in, they are still in the cafe.


 * When Nick tells Piper that he knows she froze him, you can see a clock behind the girls. The time shown on the clock is 12:25 even though it is supposed to be noon.


 * The movie Jaws didn't open for another four months from the date featured in this episode.


 * When Phoebe takes a photo of Patty with little Prue and Piper, they are in another position than when the photo is shown at the end of the episode. Patty's holding her daughters hands another way and Piper was looking in front of her instead of looking to the floor.
 * In season three in the episode Magic Hour Phoebe is discusing with Prue that she would more likely be Piper's Maid of Honor than herself because Prue had more bonding time with Piper before she was born. Prue replies that Piper was one and she was three, but in this episode Phoebe is yet to be born and little Prue and Piper are clearly much older than the ages of one and three

Out of Sight

 * When Prue runs after the Grimlock and David Hatcher, there are trees around the hole that the Grimlock opened, but when the Grimlock and David are gone, the trees are not there.


 * When Phoebe finds the underground location where the two kidnapped boys are supposedly being kept, she has her black backpack on and she still has it as she leaves to go to the Manor to fetch Prue and Piper. However when it cuts to her climbing the steps to the Manor, she no longer has the backpack on. But once inside, she is wearing it again.
 * When Prue finished making the potion for the Grimlocks, she tried to pour it inside an empty jar while you can see another jar full of green liquid on her side. After a few seconds, she received and answered a call from Phoebe, leaving the jar without any content. However, after answering the call from Phoebe, she hurriedly took two full jars which is highly impossible since she is alone and she didn't pour the potion into the jar yet.

The Power Of Two

 * When Prue drinks the potion to stop her heart we see her drink the full glass but later we see some of the red liquid left over.


 * When Phoebe and Prue are unpacking the grocery bag at the end, we can see that Phoebe is holding a cotton bag. However in the next shot, she is holding a tampon tampax box, and just taking out the cotton bag from the packet.

Love Hurts

 * In all the other episodes concerning a Darklighter, his arrows are only lethal to Whitelighters but in this episode Leo clearly states that the sisters can't touch the arrow because it is poisoned.
 * When Prue uses the Darklighter's (Alec) crossbow against him, he starts to black orb out and the arrow gets stuck in the wall behind him, but seconds later, it shows the wall and the arrow is gone.
 * When Alec orbs into the Manor, Daisy's arm change position.

Deja Vu All Over Again

 * When Piper is at Quake, Joanne says to her, "Baker High, class of '92" Though, in Coyote Piper, the board you see in the beginning of the episode says, "Baker High, class of '90"
 * When Piper and Phoebe are in the kitchen talking, we see Phoebe's hair up in a bun, but as soon as they go out to see Prue, her hair is down and clipped with two barrettes.
 * If you look very closely, just after Andy dies, you can see his throat moving.
 * At the end when Piper and Phoebe are in the kitchen talking, Piper is wearing a cross necklace. When they walk outside to talk to Prue, Piper is wearing a butterfly necklace.

Witch Trial

 * When the sisters run to the Book of Shadows, a crew member can be seen and heard crawling away.


 * When the Book falls out of the portal onto the stone altar it is noticeable that it's not the Book but rather a brown object made to look like the Book of Shadows.

Morality Bites

 * When Prue and Piper are flipping through the Book of Shadows whilst waiting for Leo to return (when they look at the folded top pages in the book) they show a close-up of the book as Prue flips through. As she does so, you can see that one of the spells is the 'Return Spell' that had 'vanished' from the book earlier.


 * When a wide-shot of the room is displayed, whilst Prue and Piper are looking through the book, a pouch can be seen between the pages. Then on the next close-up shot the pouch has vanished, but reappears in the next wide-shot.


 * When Prue and Piper first turn to the spell to create a door, there is nothing there, but the next time they turn to it, they find the prison map tucked next to the page.


 * When Prue tears out the binding spell, the spell on the page next to it (To Erase a Memory spell) has vanished.


 * When Piper draws a door on the prison wall she reaches above her head but when she and Prue walk in, they have to duck.

The Devil's Music

 * When Prue is discussing the loan deal and Chris Barker with Phoebe, she is wearing a feather necklace. However, when the sisters are talking to Leo, she is not wearing the necklace. Right before Leo orbs out, Prue is wearing the necklace again.

That Old Black Magic

 * When Jack puts the piece of paper, with Betty's address and phone number on it, in his pocket, it is folded once by Betty and then Jack sort of folds it before he puts it in his pocket. When Prue telekinetically pick-pockets Jack, it is perfectly folded twice.

They're Everywhere

 * Prue says that the Athame came from the Rowe Brothers, but that is impossible, since the athame vanished when Greg Rowe was vanquished.

P3 H2O

 * Prue's hair changed from dry to wet several times during and after the vanquish.
 * When Sam was using the memory dust on the girls Phoebe's hand keeps on changing positions from the close up to the shot with Sam and the girls
 * When Prue and Phoebe drive up to the lake in her black Mazda Miata, a cameraman and boom mic are reflected in the driver's side door as they move up to get the shot of the girls inside the car.
 * When Prue leaves Bucklands she is wearing a red top but when she arrives at the lake her top color has changed to white.
 * When Mrs. Johnson is killed, you can see the Water Demon grabbing her before he actually leaps out of the water.

Reckless Abandon

 * When the ghost doesn't freeze, Piper says to Phoebe "I've frozen ghosts before, right?". Yet, the only ghost Piper had met so far was Mark in 'Dead Man Dating' and she didn't freeze him. She was in Hawaii when Prue and Phoebe dealt with another ghost in 'The Power of Two'.
 * When Prue and Piper are changing Matthew and the camera focuses on them, you can clearly see that the baby's foot is from a doll.

Awakened

 * When Piper is cleaning up P3 after the sisters wake her up you can tell that it is on a loop since Piper cleans up the same glasses 3 or 4 times and they just keep reappearing on the bar. It also very clear that the clip is sped up and not only Piper, since the lights begin to flicker faster.

Animal Pragmatism

 * When the animal-men break into the manor, they break the window in the door in a different place than when Prue and Tessa see it later.
 * When the animal-men break into the manor, it's light outside, but it's 8 p.m. so it should be dark outside.
 * When the animal-men break into the manor, they didn't close the front door, but when all of them are on the screen, the door are closed.
 * When the Pig peels off a piece of Snake's skin, the piece he peels off is bigger than the piece he holds afterwards.
 * In the P3 Prue astral projects in and out with the crowd full of people, not just that she isn't worried about exposure, but nobody seems to notice it.
 * Prue mentions Phoebe was born in the back seat of the car, however, it was stated before that she was born in the manor. (She was saying Phoebe was conceived in the back of a car, not born) And in a future episode Piper uses Coop's ring to go back in time to find Phoebe and finds herself intruding on her parents in the act of concieving Phoebe.
 * Before Prue moves with the vase of the flowers, it's on the right side, but when Prue moves it for the first time, she moves it from the left side to the right side.
 * When the animal-men steal clothes from Ethan, in one moment you can see Snake's flesh-colored underwear, although he should be naked.
 * When Piper is hugging Dan, in the moment we see Piper's back, she has her arms around his neck, when we see Dan's back, she has her hands on his back.
 * When Piper freezes the rabbit man when he is attacking Prue, you can see him moving.
 * When Piper reads the card that Leo gave her, you can see that "for who you are, not who I think you are" is written, although when read aloud, "not who I think you are" is missing.

Astral Monkey

 * When Dr. Williamson freezes the other doctor when he walks in to his lab, the frozen doctor can be seen moving slightly.
 * When Piper pulls out the list jail patients from her pocket, it is different than the list from the computer which sisters printed in the hospital. On top of that, when the sisters were reading the list in the hospital, Piper said there was "Dr. C. Williamson", but on the paper from the hospital was written only Dr. Williamson.

Magic Hour

 * Phoebe said that Grams was married 4 times, when in season 4, she said that Grams has been married 6 times.
 * In the scene when Phoebe and Prue walk to Piper when she enters the house, we can see a microphone in the roof.
 * Prue mistakes the ages of herself and Piper before Phoebe's birth while discusing who Piper will choose for her maid of honor.

Primrose Empath

 * When Cole writes his pager number on his card he writes: 415-555-0166 but the number typed right above is 415-555-0167. He also writes pager next to the number, so this could be intentional. He may be giving out two different numbers.
 * When Prue was about to leave the dental clinic, she touched the man's butt. However, when she did that, she wasn't able to feel nor react just like the man reacted even though she was an empath.

Power Outage

 * The sisters use their powers against each other and sever the Power of Three. The Power of Three is only as strong as the sisters' bond. If their bond is broken, the power ceases to exist. While this is the reason given for the loss of their powers, Prue was the only one to use her power in an aggressive manner, when she deflected the camera back at Phoebe. Phoebe levitated to avoid the camera, and Piper froze it so that it wouldn't hit her. The same thing happens in the Season 6 episode Power Of Three Blondes when the Stillman Sisters turn against each other.
 * When two of The Triad members are killed they don't disappear, but in the Season 2 episode Ex Libris,Leo said that demons disappear when they are vanquished.
 * The triquetra on the front of the Book of Shadows changes in regards to the bond between the Charmed Ones. However in the Season 4 Premiere Charmed Again the Book shows the symbol as if Prue's death wouldn't affect The Power of Three. The same thing happens in the Season 6 episode Power Of Three Blondes when Chris provokes the Stillman Sisters into turning against each other.
 * When the triquetra on the Book splits, it's obvious that a piece of leather was placed on top of the normal triquetra.
 * When Leo brings the mineral water bottle in the living room, if you look closely, it's empty.
 * Prue used telekinetically enhanced Agility while in astral form. It was stated in previous episodes that Prue couldn't use her other powers while astral projecting.

Sleuthing With the Enemy

 * When Cole embraces Phoebe for the last time, you can see that his hand isn't bloody anymore.


 * Prue mentions that she modified the Melinda Warren summoning spell to call Belthazor, but the final spell is nothing like the original.


 * The Book Of Shadows says that there is no known way to defeat Belthazor, yet in this episode it provides not only a potion, but a vanquishing spell.


 * When Phoebe puts the bottle of potion down on the table in the mausoleum, in the next shot it has vanished.


 * When Prue and Piper are talking to Krell in the conservatory, Prue's hair switches from being behind her ear and hanging in her face for the whole shot.


 * When Julian's stun double is hit by Krell's lightning, when he lands on the patch of grass, you can tell it is fake grass covering a safety mat as it flaps as he lands.

We All Scream for Ice Cream

 * While in the alley, Freckles blows the sisters and Victor into a pile of junk. The wires used to pull the stunt doubles are clearly visible.


 * When the little girl is pulled into the truck, Prue and Phoebe grab her legs to try and save her. There are wires visible at the end of the little girls' pants.

Bride And Gloom

 * When Phoebe kicks Dantalian to the floor, she is first seen wearing black loafers of some sort. A few seconds later, when it cuts back to her, she is wearing heels.

The Good, the Bad and the Cursed

 * When Cole first shows up at the manor, he has a slight beard and mustache. But once he and Prue shimmer to the town, he's clean shaven and then has the beard and mustache again.


 * In the living room after Phoebe was shot, Prue's arms are crossed, then when in the next cut, her arms are at her sides.

Pre-Witched

 * In season 2, Kit was a female. In season's 5 episode Cat House, we learn that Kit is a Familiar, which can turn into a woman, Katrina. However, in this episode Phoebe refers to Kit by saying "him".
 * Grams previously was stated to have died in 1998 although in this episode she dies in 1997 as hinted when Prue says Grams' new bought camera was a '96 model.
 * It's noticeable that the "Grams" who falls down the stairs is a male stunt person.
 * At the beginning of the episode, Piper says that Phoebe left to go to New York for 3 years. But in the first episode they said they were together after 6 months after Grams died.
 * When Phoebe kills Shadow in the kitchen, the knife has blood on it. But from Season 2, Phoebe states that Warlocks don't bleed.

Sin Francisco

 * When the first innocent was attacked by the demon, Prue telekinetically moves the Sin box to the other side of the street where it bumps into the sidewalk. In the next scene, when the innocent runs out to get the box it is lying in the middle of the street.

Exit Strategy

 * When Piper blows up a watermelon and Phoebe asks why, Piper answers in a squeaky voice. At that moment you can see Shannen Doherty laugh, still trying to keep herself serious.

Look Who's Barking

 * Phoebe wrote "Cole's Human Form" in the Book, when technically it should have been written as "Belthazor's Human Form".
 * There was the Belthazor Vanquish Potion to the left of the Belthazor entry, as seen in Sleuthing With the Enemy, yet in this episode it is a blank page that Phoebe can add information to.
 * It is clear that the page about Cole was already written and Phoebe is pretending to write information while she is in the kitchen with Prue.
 * When Prue-Dog leaves the manor, it's clearly noticeable that the dog is a male, which doesn't make sense considering Prue is a female.
 * When Phoebe is in the attic and the Banshee comes through the window to attack, the banshee is wearing sneakers.
 * When Prue-dog is hit by the car, she gets hit on the left-hand-side. But when she changes back into Prue, she's holding her right hip as if that is where she was hit.
 * When Belthazor gets knocked over the tomb in the Mausoleum you can see his ankle which is the normal skin tone instead of the red.

All Hell Breaks Loose

 * When time resets, Prue says she felt a chill and the camera shoots to the stairs. If you look closely half a second before the camera moves to Piper, you can see a hand coming down the stairs.
 * When Prue leaves the Manor after Piper was shot, she doesn't have blood on her hands, yet when she was inside, she had.

Charmed Again

 * When Paige is reading the obituaries section of the newspaper, the text says  "Pru" instead of "Prue".

Hell Hath No Fury

 * When Phoebe kicks Piper (as a fury) and another fury while levitating, you can clearly see it's a stunt double, not Alyssa.

Black as Cole

 * Whe

A Paige from the Past

 * When Leo and Paige are sent back in time to 1994, they arrive in Paige's old room, she has a Tiffany doll from the 1998 movie Bride of Chucky and a Metallica poster on her wall of their album Garage Inc., which came out in 1998. Paige also has a Scream poster, which came out in 1996.
 * When the car gets hit by the truck and rolls, you can clearly see that it is mannequins put in place.

Charmed and Dangerous

 * After the Seer leaves the sisters after they killed The Source, Piper asks "Who whas that?" Cole answers "A very evil person" and when he's saying it, you can see the Seer's hair in the frame beside Cole on the place where she stood, for a few seconds before the actress that plays the Seer moves a little bit and leaves the frame.

Marry-Go-Round

 * The scene in which Paige accidently turns Phoebe invisible, she jumps up and down, however in the reflection on the mirror she is stood still.


 * At the wedding with the Lazarus Demon battle, Leo is seen running into the action however when Phoebe runs in (moments later), Leo has only just entered the room.

Bite Me

 * In Awakened, the sisters were concerned about doctors analyzing their blood. In this episode, both Paige and Phoebe have blood drawn for testing without any concern.
 * When Paige is on the parking lot, there is a wet road, however, when the vampires attack her, the road is dry and when vampires are flying away it's wet again.
 * Furies develop talons after their first kill, yet the fury in this episode has no talons. Considering she was present at a meeting of faction leaders, it can be assumed that this particularly fury would have made her first kill.
 * When the Vampire Queen 's assistants are bathing her, if you look closely, you can see a beige bra.

A Witch's Tail, Part 2

 * When Phoebe signs the divorce papers at the end, you see she spelled Phoebe as Pheobe (This could be in part with Alyssa Milano having dyslexia).

Happily Ever After

 * When Piper is reading the Fairy Tales book at the beginning, you can see the pages she's reading. Piper then stops reading for a while, however, once she continues reading, you can see that she's reading another page. Additionally, the things Piper reads from the Fairy Tales book aren't written in the book.
 * When Piper and Paige talk in the attic at the beginning, Piper's position and the position of the book she's holding keep changing in between shots.
 * When the Keeper's apprentice is cleaning the glass slipper, he turns his head to the Keeper, however, in the next shot, he's looking at the slipper again. Also, when the Wicked Witch strangles the Keeper of fairy tales, there's blood dripping down where she grasps him around the neck. However, when she drops him, there's no blood either on the corpse or on her hands.
 * When Phoebe and Adam bump into each other and Phoebe spills the coffee, the stains on their clothes keep changing and disappearing in between shots. Also, when Phoebe drags Cole into her office, she smiles at Adam, but in the next shot, you can see that she's not smiling.
 * When Grams is asking Piper about the things she did, Piper's hair keeps changing position.
 * When the Wicked Witch left to split the charmed ones up she left with the slippers in her hand. When she arrived at the manor she had them in a box
 * Once Phoebe starts walking out of the attic because of the Cinderella's slippers, when the shot changes, the positions of Piper, Phoebe and Penny change too. Additionally, Penny's position changes twice in the scene.
 * When the Wicked Witch tells Adam what she wants him to do, the position of her hand changes in between shots.
 * When Phoebe and Paige walk across the street, and when the horse-drawn carriage appears, their positions change in between shots.
 * When Grams, Piper, Paige and Leo are in the attic, and Grams says that she could help Paige with the protection potion, Paige's arms are crossed, however, in the next shot, her arms are not crossed anymore. Also, when Piper is scrying for the Wicked Witch, her hair keeps changing position.
 * When Phoebe arrives at the ball and stops walking, there is a close shot to her feet. However, her feet are closer to each other than they were in the previous shot.
 * When Grams is making the potion, her and Paige's positions keep changing in between shots. Additionally, when Grams asks Paige to hand her a potion vial, in one shot, Paige put the vial on the kitchen table, yet in the next one, Grams is holding it.
 * When Leo tells Phoebe about Paige being dead, Phoebe's hands change position in between shots.
 * When Phoebe "punches" Cole, if you look closely, you can see that she didn't really punch him.
 * When Cole stops the pumpkin from falling down and then picks it up, the position of the pumpkin changes.
 * When Penny, Piper, Leo, and later Cole are in the attic, the positions of Penny's hands and Piper's arms change in between shots. Also, when Penny hands Piper a vanquishing potion, Piper grabs it twice.
 * When Piper talks to the new Keeper, the positions of her hair changes in between shots. Also, when she hands him the red cloak, in one shot, she's using her right hand, yet in another shot, she's using the left one.
 * The slippers from The Wizard of Oz are the ruby ones from the 1939 film, but they were silver in the original fairy tale.

Siren Song

 * When the Siren throws Piper out the window (while they're in the hospital), the window breaks before Piper hits it.

The Eyes Have It

 * When Teresa reads Phoebe's palm, she draws lines on her hand, however, when Phoebe sat down at the table at the start, the lines were already there.
 * Phoebe said Ava wasn't in the attic in her premonition, but she is clearly seen next to Paige.

A Witch In Time

 * When Phoebe runs into the building to see if Miles is still there, she is wearing black high heeled shoes. When the leaves the building she is wearing boots.
 * In the final scene, as Phoebe leans over Miles's dead body, crying sounds are heard. However, it is clearly seen that Phoebe isn't crying (she's not shaking, her mouth isn't moving). Piper's eyes are teary, but she's not sobbing loudly or shaking either.
 * In the scene where Piper speaks with her past self, past Piper's hair alternated from curly to straight as the scene changes.

Sam, I Am

 * In P3, when Piper and Phoebe are talking about nannies and the camera is on Piper, the people in the background disappear only to reappear in the next shot.
 * Paige's lipstick changed colour from the bright red from the beginning of the episode to a darker red right in the middle of the scene where the Darklighter attacks.

Y Tu Mummy Tambien

 * Piper's hair keeps going from in front of her shoulder to behind while she is in the attic talking to Leo and Paige about Jeric.
 * Leo's haircut changes from being trimmed to longer again in between scenes.

The Importance of Being Phoebe

 * When an unconscious Phoebe is lying on the ground, Cole picks her up. You can clearly see that Alyssa puts her arms around Julian's neck.
 * When Kaia throws the knife at Phoebe, if you watch in freeze-frame, you can see that for the shot from behind her, there's no knife in her hands.
 * When Paige has her police photos taken, one shot shows her green vest on one shoulder while another shot shows it on both shoulders.

Centennial Charmed

 * On Paige's tombstone, it reads "Paige Matthews. Born 1975. Died 2001." Paige is born in 1977.
 * When Paige follows Phoebe into the kitchen, Phoebe's right earring is missing in the shots showing both sisters, but it is there in close-ups of Phoebe.

House Call

 * When the piece of ceiling falls on Piper, in the close-ups she is covered in plaster debris with a big piece sitting on top of her head. In the long-shot there is little dust and debris and no plaster chunk on her head.
 * In the very beginning of the episode right before the manifestation picks up Phoebe, you can clearly see some type of filming equipment in the upper right hand corner.
 * Also When Leo coming down the stairs after seeing that all of the sisters have been hexed, we now see a blooper showing the Dining Room ceiling has a split in it for filming.

Sand Francisco Dreamin'

 * When Phoebe gets healed by Leo up in the attic, the wound shown being healed is clearly from another shot.
 * At the scene where the sisters are going to sleep to enter their dreams Phoebe opens the conservatory door and clearly closes it again. Yet, when the camera shows Leo putting the Sandmans sand on them you can see the door is open.
 * Piper's pregnant belly disappears. Just after the baby is transferred back to Piper after Leo feels it kick, Piper's pregnant belly bump swells massively. Seconds later when she turns towards the Tracer demon her pregnant belly is missing completely (her abdomen is flat) and Leo has the belly again. When Piper turns back after blowing up the Tracer, she has the belly again.

The Day the Magic Died

 * The elastic holding the horn on the unicorn is clearly visible in most scenes featuring the animal.
 * When Leo tells Paige and Phoebe about how he can't orb, when the camera cuts to Paige and the unicorn, you can clearly see a hand in the bottom left corner, holding the unicorn.
 * When Stanley begins to strangle Paige, you can tell it's not her - it is clearly a male stunt-double.

Baby's First Demon

 * Victor was listed on the family tree as "Victor Jones" instead of "Victor Bennett".
 * Although Patty and Grams both have their full first name on the family tree, Patricia and Penelope, respectively, Prue is listed on the tree as just "Prue" not "Prudence".

Cat House

 * Paige's necklace disappears during the orbing scene.
 * When [Phoebe] goes into the bathroom while [Leo] and [Piper] are in the shower together [Phoebe] should have ran into her past self but does not.

Necromancing the Stone

 * When Grams starts her man bashing rant, Leo points out she was married 4 times, but in Lost and Bound, Phoebe stated Grams had been married 6 times. In Magic Hour, Phoebe says that Grams was married 4 times.

Oh My Goddess, Part 1

 * Piper and Phoebe talk about getting air conditioning for the manor and mention they never had it. In "Sight Unseen", Cole turned on the air conditioning to help flush out the demon Troxa.

The Power of Three Blondes

 * Even if Mabel, Mitzy and Margo had magically assumed Piper, Phoebe and Paige's identities, the Book of Shadows would still recognize them and shy away from the evil witches. The Book recognizes magic, not identities, which is why Leo and other good beings have been able to touch the Book in the past.
 * The spell the Stillman's use to strip the Charmed Ones of their powers was first used in "How to Make a Quilt Out of Americans" and, in that episode, in order for the spell to work the person's from which the powers are being extracted needed to drink a potion first. It was also ripped out by Aunt Gail. How is it back in the Book and why can the Stillman's - simple, common witches - cast a spell and absorb the Charmed Ones' powers by only reciting the spell when the Power of Three requires a potion? This is seen again with Zankou.
 * When the Stilman's follow the Charmed Ones to the attic, after Pipers yell's, "Go!" Mabel Freezes the scene. If you watch closely in the back ground, when she frezes the scene, Pheobe and Paige freeze at different times. Watch Pheobe freeze then glance over to Paige and you'll see her freeze almost a second or two later!

Love's a Witch

 * The exterior of Anthony's, where Piper and Seth eat dinner, is the same building used for Quake's exterior in season one.
 * Drew Fuller's hair keeps changing throughout the episode. In one scene it is very neatly combed then in the next it is messy and then in the following scene it is neat again.
 * Piper recites the "To Call a Lost Witch" spell and says it was not working, but she was not performing the accompanying ritual that the Book says must be done in conjunction with the spell, as shown in Charmed Again, Part 1.
 * At then end of the episode where Phoebe has locked herself in the attic, she has clearly locked the door. Yet after Piper and Paige take the potion her and Paige go downstaires, she doesn't unlock the door while opening it, she just opens it.
 * When they do the spell to see the ghost phoebe unlocked hands with piper when they are to be holding hands.

My Three Witches

 * The basement in which Paige finds the little girl hiding is the same set used for the Halliwell's basement in the manor.

Witchstock

 * Phoebe and Paige discuss that Paige was born in the year of the ox, but the only year of the ox during the 1970s was 1973, which would make her as old as Piper.
 * When the sisters went back to 1975 in That 70s Episode, Grams appeared to be in her forties or fifties but in this episode Grams appears to be in her late 20s in 1967.


 * The calendar that Paige notices says that it is January of 1967, but at the hippie gathering Paige attends the weather seems to reflect a spring or summer month.


 * On the family tree that appeared in episodes Pardon My Past and Baby's First Demon, Patty's father - the sisters' grandfather - is listed as Jack Halliwell and not Allen. Also, his death date is listed as 1964 and not 1967.


 * Just after Wyatt tries to orb his bottle to himself, when Chris, Grams, and Leo (holding Wyatt) come running downstairs to get away from the demon with no name, it is clearly visible that Grams is a stunt double and that Leo is actually holding a large doll.

Used Karma

 * Phoebe calls Jason "mi amor." Mata Hari speaks French, and she is supposed to say "mon amour" (which is also written in the closed captions). Mi amor and mon amour are the Spanish and French respective translations for "my love." Mata Hari, a Dutch-born French stripper who was believed to be a double agent for the German would have no reason to say that line in Spanish.
 * When Phoebe and Paige orbed into the cave to help Piper, Piper was hit by a fireball and left a mark on her forehead; but when the three orb back to the manor Piper's wound is gone.
 * When the sisters were in the catacombs, they were talking by a corner, and their position in the corridor changes from camera shot to camera shot. When we're looking at Phoebe and Paige straight on, they're in front of the corner, but when the camera angle switches to show Piper's face and the sides of Phoebe and Paige, Phoebe has her hand up on the wall, and all three of them are standing next to the wall (around the corner).
 * When Mata Hari's karma first enters Phoebe's body, Phoebe has a premonition of Mata Hari being executed by the French firing squad. You can hear a woman sobbing and begging and pleading in French. People don't normally watch firing squad executions (like at hangings), so this must have been Mata Hari that was sobbing and pleading. But later, when Jason is about to be executed, Mata Hari tells Jason that when she died, she looked her executioners right in the eye, no begging or anything of the sort.
 * Piper scolds Leo for turning off the serenading Mozart, because she believes it will discourage Wyatt from turning evil, but back in Womb Raider, Phoebe was playing Mozart to the baby in her womb to calm it and Piper scoffed at her.

The Legend of Sleepy Halliwell

 * They put Sigmund's head in an opaque bag but when they get to the school, he's able to see the girl who's levitating.
 * When the Shaman is handing Phoebe the drink in one of those scenes, her grasp on the container keeps switching between the handle and the bowl part of it.

I Dream of Phoebe

 * Leo reads the Arabic warning on Jinny's bottle incorrectly. Arabic is read from right to left, he should have spun the bottle the other way around.

The Courtship of Wyatt's Father

 * In this episode Gideon starts to plot against Wyatt considering him evil. In early episodes of season 6 Wyatt used his forcefield against Chris - why did he not sense Gideon's negative attitude and plans?

Hyde School Reunion

 * Phoebe glamours Rick into Chris and knowingly allows the Scabbars to kill him ... It goes against the Wiccan Rede and everything that the sisters stand for doing that ... the sisters are not to kill humans no matter how bad or guilty they are. What happened to the fact that the girls are supposed to "protect the innocent, not punish the guilty", as seen in Morality Bites?


 * In the scenes where the camera is outside of the car as Phoebe is driving, you can see her stunt double's face clearly.

Crimes and Witch-Demeanors

 * During the exchange about Piper not being present at the tribunal, the word "abstentia" is used. The correct word is "absentia".
 * Gideon's initial invocation to the Tribunal, translated, basically means, "I say, behold this hour, for my wife will kill me."
 * When the Cleaners arrive for the first time in the market place, you can see that they are in front of a greenscreen as parts of Phoebe's sleeves disappear as they turn to look at them.

Witch Wars
Its a Bad Bad Bad World Part 2
 * The demon in the beginning (and later Leo confirmed this) said that the good witch killed at the start had the ability to shoot fire from her hands. However, in We're Off to See the Wizard Leo sees Phoebe use such a power and states that it is an upper level demonic power.
 * When chris telekineticlly throws Daryl out of the manor ,Daryl is on a flat surface but he should be on the steps because the frount porch is only 3-5 feet long.

A Call to Arms

 * In the first scene in the kitchen when Piper comes in, she is wearing slippers of fur and a little while later when we see a full frontal of her, she is suddenly wearing flip flops.
 * The exterior of the Bay Mirror is now a totally different building then it was the previous season, even though Phoebe's office is the same interior set.

Cheaper by the Coven

 * The spell to summon the dead changed; Paige said: "Hear me now, hear my cry, spirit from the other side, cross now the great divide." Originally it was "Hear these words, hear this cry, spirit from the other side, come to me, I summon thee, cross now the great divide."
 * The sign at the award ceremony says, "San Francisco Bay Area Reader's Choice Awards." Unless there was only one reader, it should correctly say, "...Readers' Choice Awards."

Charrrmed!

 * How did Agent Brody and Sheridan get to the Pirate's cave? Paige, Piper, and Phoebe only got there by sensing it with the coin and then orbing there.
 * Just before Piper freezes Inspector Sheridan, the Inspector says "Look, if you think that this is going to get me off ..." then is frozen. When she is unfrozen, she says "... get me off your tail." She repeats the same part over.
 * In the last part of Phoebe's maneuver at the museum, she clearly steps on one of the lasers. Wouldn't it have been simpler to just let Leo orb the Chalice to them? Or they could have brought Paige and had her telekinetically orb it to them, just because Paige was old didn't mean she still didn't have her power.
 * Old Paige's shoes change when the rest of her clothing doesn't. Originally Paige was wearing high-heeled pumps.
 * If the parrot was a ghost (as we see at the end when it dissolves with the pirates) and could only travel at night by fog, then how did it get to the manor in the daytime?
 * When we see Leo sleeping at the end, the book on his chest appears/disappears/reappears in sequential shots.
 * When Paige is younger her eyes are brown but when they show her as an older woman her eyes are blue.

Someone to Witch Over Me

 * The burning building at the beginning is shown to be at the corner of Polk and Gough. These two streets exist in San Francisco, but they run parallel and do not meet as shown here.
 * We see the body of the guy who got hit by the speeding truck and it's...well, intact. Someone hit that hard by a vehicle moving that fast would not be in any shape like what we see of the corpse here.
 * Why do they need a vanquishing potion for the Celerity Demon? Piper can just blow it up with her power.

There's Something About Leo

 * How long have Wyatt and Chris had their own room? Wasn't there this whole big problem in the fifth season about Piper and Leo not having room for the baby and having to turn their closet into a nursery? No one has left the house and no renovations have been done since A Witch's Tail, Part 1.
 * In the scene where Leo tells Piper he's an Avatar there is a continuance problem. You can clearly see Piper with her back to the camera, putting the Orange basket on the table and taking the beetle toe, but when you see here a second later from the front she is again putting the Orange basket down and taking the beetle toe.
 * When the Enoch Demons are attacking the girls, they stay invisible. When the dye is thrown they are revealed to be seen holding energy balls, however Piper had just mentioned, not three seconds before, that they have to become visible to attack. If they have to become visible, why didn't they?

Witchness Protection

 * When the demons go to free Zankou, the Wizard says the spell and sticks his staff into the rock formation and turns it. You can clearly see he is turning a movable piece that was put into the rock.

Ordinary Witches

 * The street Brody and Paige emerge in past NY is the same as in Charmed Noir just in color.
 * The newspaper that confirms the date is the "New York Monitor". However, for some strange reason, it features The New York Times's "All The News That's Fit To Print" motto on its upper-left-hand corner.
 * On the cab that doesn't stop there is an ad for "Raiders of the Lost Ark". But this was released in June 1981 and it's extremely unlikely that there are still ads on a cab advertising that movie in December.
 * Why did Phoebe and Ronnie both freeze? Phoebe is still a good witch even without her powers. If not, why did Ronnie freeze then? Wouldn't Phoebe's powers make him a good witch too? The same goes for when Piper and Phoebe were both frozen - it was established before that when the sisters active powers are stolen, they still have spell casting abilities. Hence they are still good witches, so again, why would they freeze?

Extreme Makeover: World Edition

 * At the beginning when Paige orbs out, to fight a demon, she leaves a page in the Book of Shadows stuck open, however when Kyle goes to the book to find the Elders the page is flat.

Charmageddon

 * When Phoebe and Piper are in the kitchen cooking for the party, Phoebe mixes something in a bowl and then pours it into the pie crust on the counter. However in the next shot Phoebe goes to put the pie crust into the oven and it is empty.

Carpe Demon

 * Previously, Astral Projection had been presented as something one is either born with or matures into, and it makes no sense that it is now a skill anyone with sufficient motivation can master. However, in the last episode of the 7th season, Something Wicca This Way Goes...?, the sisters use it to lure Zankou into Magic School and Piper says, "Thank you, Prue," indicating that Prue left tips in the Book of Shadows to explain how to astral-project.

Show Ghouls

 * At the end, even though the on-screen band consists of only a pianist and a trumpet player, the actual music we hear them play has a rather extensive strings section.

The Seven Year Witch

 * When Sandra says "Leo was not just someone, Piper. He was an Elder, by his own choice", that is completely incorrect and untrue, it was not Leo's choice to become or be an Elder. The Elders made him one without his consent as seen in Season 5.
 * When Piper accuses Cole of choosing to become the Source, Cole agrees with this. Even through he was possessed by the Source against his will in season 4.

Freaky Phoebe

 * When Piper says "Demons never attack at P3!", she must have forgotten about Jeremy in Witch Trial, Devlin and his coupe in Muse to My Ears, the Rat Demons, etc.


 * Paige introduces Michael as her first charge however her first charge was Sam Wilder (her father) in the episode Sam I Am.

Imaginary Fiends

 * Future Wyatt should not have been able to use his powers, we learned in That '70s Episode that Prue, Piper, and Phoebe were not able to use magic because their past selves already existed in that time. Although, it could have been that the reason they weren't able to use their powers was because the Charmed Ones didn't fully exist at this time so their powers weren't complete like Patty said.

Death Becomes Them

 * In The Wendigo, Phoebe knew how to change a tire, and was about to tell Piper how to do it herself over the phone, yet in this episode, she has no knowledge of how to change a tire, or what a tire-iron looks like, unless she was just pretending to not know, just to be a bit flirty.
 * Every time the camera focuses on Joanna (3 times) you see the same bald man pass her in the same direction every time.
 * In Coyote Piper, the Alchemist demon was able to bring the dead back to life, or at least make them animate again. So why did the Alchemist in this episode need Zankou to bring him to life again, if he already has the power to do so?

Something Wicca This Way Goes...?

 * The potion/spell to remove a witch's powers was ripped from the Book in How to Make a Quilt Out of Americans and yet it is now back in the Book for Zankou to use.
 * When the potion to strip a witch's power was used in season 2 it required that the victim swallow it, throwing it wasn't enough. The potion itself wasn't enough since they needed to read a spell. The powers could only be transferred from the sisters to Cryto after Aunt Gail laced the girls' iced tea with it and then the powers could only be removed from Cryto and given back to the girls by shoving the potion down his throat while frozen.
 * In the basement, Phoebe is wearing heels, but when Zankou throws them into the debris, she can clearly be seen wearing tennis shoes.

Still Charmed and Kicking

 * In most scenes, the "reflections" are wearing their hair differently than the real sisters. For example, when Piper and Phoebe are shoe-shopping and look into the store window for reflection, the real Phoebe has her hair in a ponytail, but her reflection is wearing her hair down.
 * When Piper and Phoebe walk out of the store their own reflections are visible in the door, however when they look into the window, it's their fake identities instead.
 * When Billie is first shown she has knee-length stiletto boots but when she lands on the movie theater seat she has almost flat boots on.
 * Julie and Jo Bennett are credited with the last name Bennet.
 * When they look in the mirror after saying the spell, and Paige hears the call it shows (in her reflection) she is touching her head but when it went back to the real Paige it shows her hand still going to her head.
 * There is a filming glitch in the scene when Victor is washing dishes and chatting with Leo. The back of the counter where the sink is can be seen. Normally, there is a wall and a window there.

Malice in Wonderland

 * After the family meeting, Paige goes upstairs and her true reflection can be seen.
 * In one scene Phoebe is holding "Sex & the City: The Complete Series" but the complete series DVD set hadn't been released yet.
 * When Billie fell, her sunglasses disappeared.
 * While Piper is talking to Leo about how her life flew by she makes errors. She says that she was fresh from college, trying to become a chef, and single. She then goes on to say how she became a witch. However, when Piper was out of college, she became an accountant though she had desired to become a chef. She also was not single because she was engaged to Jeremy Burns.

Desperate Housewitches

 * Paige asks Phoebe how they destroyed the Source the last time, even though Paige was present during both Source vanquishes. Phoebe also mentions using potions, though the Source was vanquished with a spell.
 * The Source says that the sisters couldn't hurt him without the Hollow, which is an incorrect statement as it was the Source who summoned the Hollow to defeat the sisters.
 * The Source's skin color has changed, in season 4, it was powder white but now his skin is more flesh colored.
 * During Wyatt's school play, Leo's camera changes.

Rewitched

 * When Piper is convincing Paige into speed-dating at the beginning of the episode, Piper's and Paige's arms keep changing their position every time screen changes. Also the things Piper is holding keep changing with screen changes.
 * When Leo comes to ask Piper for Tylenol, you can see that instead of mirror there is a green screen.
 * When Phoebe and Dex are kissing in front of the Manor before and after they got married, their positions keep changing in between shots.
 * During the speed-dating, people in the background keep changing.
 * After Piper talks to Paige about the 'family emergency', Paige goes back to her table and sits down, but when the scene cuts back to Piper, Paige is standing up and is about to sit down.
 * When Paige looks at herself in the window after Whit calls her Jo, her relection is shaking her head while she is not.
 * When Phoebe and Paige are talking in the Manor, Phoebe's arms change position during screen changes.
 * Paige's scrying lands on the map coordinates of Union and Fillmore Streets in Pacific Heights while it is supposed to be the coordinates of the Manor on Prescott Street.
 * The Department of Homeland Security's San Francisco field office official seal is incorrect.
 * When Phoebe comes to Dex's flat, his arms keep changing position when the screen changes.

Kill Billie Vol. 1

 * Kaley Cuoco misreads the second part of the memory spell twice in a row by omitting the second "my".

The Lost Picture Show

 * Cigarettes don't set off smoke detectors.
 * San Francisco has banned Segway scooters from their sidewalks 5 years ago.

Battle of the Hexes

 * In the book the demons find at Magic School, Hippolyta is misspelled "Hippolytal".

Vaya Con Leos

 * In one scene, it is clearly visible that a being in one of the frozen cubes is a mannequin.

Mr. & Mrs. Witch

 * A homeless guy walked past a subway station. San Francisco does not have subway stations.
 * Grant Pelham is credited as Chuck Pelham.
 * Carl Jenkins was summoned to the manor through the "Lost Witch" spell, while it was established that his daughters gained their magic from their mother's side.

12 Angry Zen

 * The length of Henry's hair changes throughout the episode.
 * As established, this episode takes place on January 29th, the Chinese New Year. But in "Payback's A Witch", they celebrated Wyatt's birthday, which is on February 2nd.

The Last Temptation of Christy

 * When Henry is proposing to Paige, a green outline can be seen around them from the green screen.

Engaged and Confused

 * When one of The Triad freezes the room to talk to Christy, Piper's face is different from when it unfreezes to when it was first frozen.
 * The pentagrams on the robes worn by Candor changes, at first it is pointing down and then points up in the last scene.

Generation Hex

 * While in the past, ("The Honeymoon's Over") Phoebe mentions the school is where she first met Cole. She actually met him at a crime scene the night before, this is likely because Prue was with Phoebe when Cole met her, and they were unable to show footage of Prue due to behind the scenes issues.
 * The clip of Phoebe and Jason from "My Three Witches" was flipped. In the original scene, Phoebe was on the left and Jason was on the right. In the flashback Jason is on the left and Phoebe is on the right.

The Jung and the Restless

 * When the girls collapsed after being put to sleep by Billie and Christy, the position of Piper's hands change in between scenes.

Gone With the Witches

 * After catching Phoebe and Coop kissing, Piper goes to the Book of Shadows which is open on the Truth Spell. She flicks through a couple of pages and stops, but the page shown in the close up is the Truth Spell again.

Forever Charmed

 * After Wyatt gets his powers, he orbs to Piper's side to prove that he has gotten them back. A portion of the stained windows' frame in the sun room moves, behind Piper and Wyatt as Wyatt orbed.
 * The last time the Hollow was used, all powers were restored once it had been dispelled, yet Wyatt still loses his powers after the Hollow has been cast out of Billie and Christy.
 * When Piper, Leo and Patty travel to the past to find Grams, Piper introduces Leo when Grams doesn't recognize him, however this contradicts "Witchstock", in which Grams already knew Leo.